Murphy’s Logic: PM and premiers need more accountability
We don’t vote directly for our prime ministers and premiers. The job usually goes to the person who leads the party that wins a general election.
Since the Canadian constitution, and its British progenitor, contain no real job definition, there are no strict restrictions on the powers of the first minister. The style and extent of how it’s exercised is determined by the ambition, personality and values of the person who has the job.
Most of the power flows from his or her prerogative to appoint and fire cabinet ministers.
Cabinets are supposed to make decisions by consensus but as a practical matter, only ministers who promise and deliver fidelity to the premier can expect to remain in the inner circle. So it’s often the premier’s way or the highway, particularly on controversial issues.
We’ve seen a clear illustration of this in New Brunswick lately. Premier Blaine Higgs has been accused of “autocratic leadership” as he pursues controversial policies with single-minded determination. Some of his ministers have quit, others have been replaced. Higgs now faces a leadership challenge.
But once entrenched, removing a premier can be a very complicated process.
The problem with our system, is that people whose powers are not defined, are not easily restrained. It is an invitation to autocracy.
One way to blunt some of that power would be to adopt the recent practice of the British conservative party. It allows letters from only 15% of the party’s elected members to trigger a confidential confidence vote on the leader. If the leader loses, they’re out.
The caucus then nominates two candidates — and all of the party members vote. It’s direct and it’s quick.
Granting such power to caucus members and cabinet ministers would make premiers more accountable to voters, through their elected representatives — and give premiers an incentive to find compromise and consensus — to get along or go home.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Trudeau's 2024: Did the PM become less popular this year?
Justin Trudeau’s numbers have been relatively steady this calendar year, but they've also been at their worst, according to tracking data from CTV News pollster Nik Nanos.
Manhunt underway after woman, 23, allegedly kidnapped, found alive in river
A woman in her 20s who was possibly abducted by her ex is in hospital after the car she was in plunged into the Richelieu River.
Death toll in attack on Christmas market in Germany rises to 5 and more than 200 injured
Germans on Saturday mourned both the victims and their shaken sense of security after a Saudi doctor intentionally drove into a Christmas market teeming with holiday shoppers, killing at least five people, including a small child, and wounding at least 200 others.
Overheated immigration system needed 'discipline' infusion: minister
An 'overheated' immigration system that admitted record numbers of newcomers to the country has harmed Canada's decades-old consensus on the benefits of immigration, Immigration Minister Marc Miller said, as he reflected on the changes in his department in a year-end interview.
Wild boar hybrid identified near Fort Macleod, Alta.
Acting on information, an investigation by the Municipal District of Willow Creek's Agricultural Services Board (ASB) found a small population of wild boar hybrids being farmed near Fort Macleod.
Summer McIntosh makes guest appearance in 'The Nutcracker'
Summer McIntosh made a splash during her guest appearance in The National Ballet of Canada’s production of 'The Nutcracker.'
The winter solstice is here, the Northern Hemisphere's darkest day
The winter solstice is Saturday, bringing the shortest day and longest night of the year to the Northern Hemisphere — ideal conditions for holiday lights and warm blankets.
22 people die in a crash between a passenger bus and a truck in Brazil
A crash between a passenger bus and a truck early Saturday killed 22 people on a highway in Minas Gerais, a state in southeastern Brazil, officials said.
Back on air: John Vennavally-Rao on reclaiming his career while living with cancer
'In February, there was a time when I thought my career as a TV reporter was over,' CTV News reporter and anchor John Vennavally-Rao writes.