N.L. doctor testifies about COVID-19 transmission risks of lifting travel ban
Published Thursday, August 6, 2020 8:28AM ADT Last Updated Thursday, August 6, 2020 2:32PM ADT
Newfoundland and Labrador's provincial flag flies on a flag pole in Ottawa, Friday July 3, 2020. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld)
ST. JOHN'S, N.L. -- Newfoundland and Labrador's COVID-19 infection rate could be 20 times higher in the absence of a travel ban, the doctor leading a team running models on the contagion said Thursday in court.
Dr. Proton Rahman testified before the province's Supreme Court during a legal challenge to the travel restrictions authorities imposed in May to slow the spread of COVID-19.
Newfoundland and Labrador's chief medical officer of health, Dr. Janice Fitzgerald, is also set to take the stand as a witness in the proceedings scheduled this week in St. John's. She ordered special measures this spring that banned anyone but permanent residents and workers deemed essential from entering the province.
In May, Halifax resident Kim Taylor and the Canadian Civil Liberties Association filed a claim alleging the restrictions fall outside the province's jurisdiction and violate the charter.
Taylor was initially denied a request to travel to Newfoundland after her mother died. That decision was later reversed and she was granted an exemption, but she says it came too late.
Rahman, a clinical epidemiologist and professor of medicine at Memorial University of Newfoundland, testified Thursday about with his work with the modelling group.
His team helps the province and other institutions with predictive analysis on issues such as potential surges of COVID-19 cases. Rahman said his team was asked by the province to run modelling scenarios in June for the court case.
The results, he said, showed a "10-fold higher rate of cases in the province" over a nine-week period without a travel restriction in place. A second scenario showed a case rate that was five-to-20-fold higher over 14 weeks without a travel restriction, he said.
Rahman also told the court about a paper he co-authored with Stanford University and Oxford University professors analyzing the impact of lifting the travel ban in the province.
The paper dated July 17 is not yet peer-reviewed. Researchers used machine learning and an epidemiological model to look at COVID-19 dynamics in various reopening scenarios. The results suggest that a full border reopening would see a new COVID-19 case in the province "every other day."
The authors wrote that while relaxing travel restrictions is "a highly contentious political decision," tight border measures are a clearly effective strategy to control cases.
"From an outbreak dynamics perspective, the picture is quite clear: Without proper control, an influx of infected travellers can easily become the seed for a new exponential outbreak," the study read. "Our study shows that especially for smaller provinces or states ... tight border control is often easier and more effective than quarantine."
The authors also noted "local travel bubbles" are a reasonable first step when relaxing travel restrictions. Newfoundland and Labrador joined the other Atlantic provinces in a regional "bubble" in July, allowing residents to travel within the region without self-isolating upon arrival.
The paper also cites health factors in the province that are "critical" to analyze when developing COVID-19 policies, noting Newfoundland and Labrador has high rates of smoking, obesity, metabolic disease and cancer.
Fitzgerald was set to appear as a witness Thursday, but the proceedings were cut short after a lawyer working on the case felt ill and was unable to return to the courtroom. Rahman is scheduled to resume his testimony in court Friday morning.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published August 6, 2020.