Nova Scotia becomes first province to stop holding immigration detainees
Nova Scotia has become the first province to stop holding immigration detainees in its jails on behalf of the federal government.
Canada Border Services Agency spokeswoman Rebecca Purdy says the province ended the practice Aug. 8.
Other provinces, including British Columbia and Alberta, have said they too would stop holding immigration detainees. However, both of those provinces have agreed to temporarily continue housing high-risk detainees in jails, but are not accepting new inmates.
"Nova Scotia, like other provinces, has determined that provincial correctional facilities are not the appropriate place for individuals who are being held solely under the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act," Nova Scotia's Department of Justice said in a statement.
"As a result, we notified Canada Border Services Agency last year that our province would not renew the agreement to hold detainees on their behalf."
The end of the detention deal has been saluted by immigrant-rights activists, who have said detainees often face solitary confinement and lockdowns in provincial jails even though they aren't charged with crimes in Canada.
Ali Bhagat, assistant professor at the school of public policy at Simon Fraser University, said Nova Scotia's decision is good news. "Detention really does violate people's human rights," he said. "I think ending this practice is a really good thing."
Jay Ramasubramanyam, assistant professor at York University's social science department, said that if Canada wants to proclaim itself as a bastion of human rights, then immigration detention should end. But, he said, provinces ending their detention agreements with Ottawa won't make it any easier for migrants to obtain status in Canada.
"It's a false equivalency to think that as soon as immigration detention with provinces tend to end, then people are going to be able to walk in or walk around their neighbourhood free," he said. "That's not going to happen."
Purdy said the agency considers a number of factors for detaining migrants.
"Immigration detention requires several elements, including that an individual be inadmissible to Canada and either poses a flight risk and a danger to the public, due to a past criminal history involving violence or otherwise violent behaviour," she said in an email.
The agency runs its own immigration detention centres in Laval, Que., Toronto, and Surrey, B.C., and had entered into arrangements with all provinces for holding immigration detainees in regions outside those three centres.
Saskatchewan is slated to end its agreement with the agency on Sept. 30, while Manitoba and Ontario are set to terminate their deals next year. The agency does not have formal agreements with Prince Edward Island or Newfoundland and Labrador but works with them on a case-by-case basis, Purdy said.
Canada's border services agency has cut the number of detained migrants in provincial jails by more than half within six years, she said, from 2,043 in 2016-17 to 931 in 2022-23.
About three-quarters of the migrants held in provincial correctional facilities are inadmissible into Canada for reasons of serious criminality, Purdy said. "This means the person has been convicted of an offence in Canada or abroad, such as sexual offences, violence, weapons or drug trafficking," she said.
"Over the past 10 years, there have been at least 441 people in provincial correctional facilities with links to organized crime in the Americas and Asia, she said. "These individuals were found to be inadmissible to Canada and Canada Border Services Agency assessed that they would continue to carry out activities related to organized crime and possibly disappear to avoid removal."
Ramasubramanyam said most migrants are detained in Canada because of administrative reasons, not because they are criminals. It is "very unlikely," he said, that someone with a criminal history is going to make it past immigration protocols.
Bhagat, meanwhile, said the end of detention agreements between provinces and Ottawa isn't making the country less safe, because border officials are still able to detain people.
"The deal is just speaking to the idea that Canada Border Services Agency is no longer paying provinces to host migrants in their provincial jails. That's the thing that's being ended."
Migrant detention is practised in a number of countries, such as the United Kingdom, Australia and the United States, said both experts.
"It's not an uncommon practice," Ramasubramanyam said. "Though they may not be viewed as practices of detention. It's still a form of detention."
"The fact that Nova Scotia is ending its immigration detention process is actually a step in the right direction."
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Sept. 1, 2023.
For more Nova Scotia news visit our dedicated provincial page.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Aviation experts say Russia's air defence fire likely caused Azerbaijan plane crash as nation mourns
Aviation experts said Thursday that Russian air defence fire was likely responsible for the Azerbaijani plane crash the day before that killed 38 people and left all 29 survivors injured.
Police identify victim of Christmas Day homicide in Hintonburg, charge suspect
The Ottawa Police Service says the victim who had been killed on Christmas Day in Hintonburg has been identified.
Teen actor Hudson Meek, who appeared in 'Baby Driver,' dies after falling from moving vehicle
Hudson Meek, the 16-year-old actor who appeared in 'Baby Driver,' died last week after falling from a moving vehicle in Vestavia Hills, Alabama, according to CNN affiliate WVTM.
Boxing Day in Canada: Small retailers fear big shopping day won't make up for tough year
It’s one of the busiest shopping days of the year: Boxing Day sees thousands of people head to malls and big box stores to find great deals. But it's not so simple for smaller shops.
Raised in Sask. after his family fled Hungary, this man spent decades spying on communists for the RCMP
As a Communist Party member in Calgary in the early 1940s, Frank Hadesbeck performed clerical work at the party office, printed leaflets and sold books.
Sinkhole prompts lane closures on Interstate 80 in New Jersey
A sinkhole that opened up Thursday along Interstate 80 in northern New Jersey forced authorities to close the heavily travelled highway's eastbound lanes.
Cat food that caused bird-flu death of Oregon pet was distributed in B.C.: officials
Pet food contaminated with bird flu – which killed a house cat in Oregon – was distributed and sold in British Columbia, according to officials south of the border.
Police in New Brunswick investigating Christmas Eve sudden death
An unconscious individual was found in the 600-block area of Lancaster Avenue early Christmas Eve morning, and was later pronounced dead at a hospital.
Pizza deliverer in Florida charged with stabbing pregnant woman at motel after tip dispute
A pizza deliverer in central Florida has been charged with pushing her way into a motel room with an accomplice and stabbing a pregnant woman after a dispute over a tip, authorities said.