Some experts not so 'sweet' on N.L. soft-drink tax
After the province of Newfoundland and Labrador announced details on its so-called "sugary drink" tax Tuesday, some experts are advising caution on the approach.
The Newfoundland government plans to put a 20-cent per litre tax on beverages with added sugars, which it projects will bring in about $9 million a year. The tax will be applied on top of provincial sales tax starting Sept. 1 next year.
Some drinks are excluded, including chocolate milk, diet drinks using artificial sweeteners, and infant formulas.
For Sara Kirk, a professor of health promotion at Dalhousie University, the idea of taxing sugar-sweetened drinks to reduce consumption is a good one.
But she also says it's how it's done that matters most.
"We're looking for a sweet spot really in terms of how we do that," says Kirk.
While she says there is evidence from other jurisdictions that have a similar tax in place that sugar consumption does decrease, every context is different.
"The U.K. one was very much aimed at industry," she says as an example.
That was a levy introduced in 2018 and taxes the manufacturer rather than the consumer.
According to a study published this year in a British medical journal, while Brits didn't reduce the volume of soft drink they purchased, their sugar consumption did drop. That's because producers reduced the amount of sugar in their drinks in response to the levy.
"What you really want to be doing with a tax, is changing individual behaviour but also changing the behaviour of industry," says Kirk.
But, there is concern among experts about what the tax could mean for those who simply can't afford the rising cost of healthier options.
Jennifer Brady of MSVU's Applied Human Nutrition department says any reduction in sugar consumption is outweighed by the potential harm to those who may rely on those kinds of drinks.
"Putting a tax on sugar-sweetened beverages disproportionately burdens those who drink more sugar-sweetened beverages," she says, "And does that include? It includes poor or low-income families who really can't afford to spend more on their groceries."
Brady points to the high cost of alternatives such as milk. She would like to see a different approach.
"Increasing access for poor families to healthy foods or better yet, improve their ability to afford a healthy diet is essentially what it comes down to for me," she says.
That's something Kirk says could be done, by using the revenue from a sugar tax to fund healthy food initiatives.
"To have something like a subsidized food program," she says, "or subsidies on healthy foods like fruits and vegetables as well."
The Canadian Taxpayers Federation, meanwhile, calls the idea "a tax grab."
"It will increase the cost of living at the worst possible time," says CTF federal director Franco Terrazano, "and it will mean the most pain, for those who can least afford it."
For registered dietitian Meredith Lapp, who often helps her clients cut back their sugar intake, sugar-sweetened drinks are just the tip of the iceberg.
"The problem really becomes that sugar is so prevalent in our food supply," she says.
That's part of the reason she believes says taxing sugar-sweetened beverages doesn't look at the whole picture.
"Access to clean water, access to nutrient dense local foods … finding ways to support or incentivize foods in schools for example," she says.
As for whether any Maritime provinces will be following Newfoundland and Labrador's example, Nova Scotia's Minister of Health and Wellness said today the province isn't considering it.
"I think what would be important would be to understand whether the evidence points to whether or not it creates behavior change," said Michelle Thompson.
"What's really important is that we look at an upstream approach where we create public policy where a healthy choice is the easy choice."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
'Most horrific': Alberta First Nation investigating after remains of children found
Saddle Lake Cree Nation in eastern Alberta is 'actively researching and investigating' the deaths of at least 200 residential school children who never came home, as remains are being found in unmarked grave sites.

Prince Charles offers remarks about reconciliation as Canadian tour begins
Prince Charles and Camilla, the Duchess of Cornwall, have arrived in St. John's, N.L., to begin a three-day Canadian tour that includes stops in Ottawa and the Northwest Territories.
Alberta premier urges U.S. senators to convince Michigan to stop Line 5 shutdown
Alberta Premier Jason Kenney is urging the U.S. government to convince Michigan to abandon its legal campaign against the Line 5 pipeline.
Former Pentagon officials briefed Canadian MPs on UFOs, MP and researcher say
Former Pentagon officials have briefed at least three Canadian members of Parliament about unidentified flying objects, according to a Manitoba MP and a Texas-based researcher.
Poilievre personally holds investment in Bitcoin as he promotes crypto to Canadians
Conservative Party leadership candidate Pierre Poilievre has a personal financial interest in cryptocurrencies that he has promoted during his campaign as a hedge against inflation.
First transgender federal party leader calls for national anti-trans hate strategy
The Green Party of Canada is calling on the federal government to develop a targeted anti-transgender hate strategy, citing a 'rising tide of hate' both in Canada and abroad. Amita Kuttner, who is Canada's first transgender federal party leader, made the call during a press conference on Parliament Hill on Tuesday.
Airport delays: Transport minister says feds not asking airlines to cut back flights
Canada's transport minister is dismissing claims that the federal government asked airlines to reduce their schedules and cancel flights to ease recent travel delays.
Regular travel and public health measures can't coexist: Canadian Airport Council
International arrivals at Canadian airports are so backed up, people are being kept on planes for over an hour after they land because there isn't physically enough space to hold the lineups of travellers, says the Canadian Airports Council.
Maple Leafs star Mitch Marner carjacked at gunpoint outside Toronto movie theatre
A day after Maple Leafs star Mitch Marner was robbed of his Range Rover at gunpoint outside an Etobicoke movie theatre, Toronto police said they have already seen more carjackings so far this year than they did in all of 2021.