Supreme Court won't hear appeal of Nova Scotia man's 'Grabher' licence plate case
A Nova Scotia man's long fight to get back a personalized licence plate bearing his surname, "Grabher," came to an abrupt end Thursday as the Supreme Court of Canada declined to hear an appeal of his case.
As is customary, the court did not give reasons for its decision in denying Lorne Grabher leave to appeal.
Grabher's defence team had maintained that a previous Nova Scotia Supreme Court ruling violated his right to freedom of expression.
"We are disappointed with the decision," said Grabher's lawyer, Jay Cameron of the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms.
Cameron said there was no evidence "whatsoever" that Grabher's licence plate had caused harm to anyone in the community at large. He pointed out that the surname is of Austrian-German origin.
"In order to make his name mean anything, you have to anglicize his name and add words to it, which is what the government has done and then it has censored them," Cameron said in an interview. "I think that there is still a problem with the way that the law is being interpreted here."
He pointed out that a "Grabher" plate is currently in use in Alberta, while he said a Manitoba court had previously ruled that the charter does apply to personalized licence plates. Grabher was not immediately available for comment Thursday.
His Nova Scotia plate, which he had for nearly 30 years, was recalled by the province's Registrar of Motor Vehicles in December 2016 after it received a complaint that the word promoted hatred toward women.
He first took the matter to court in 2017, arguing the registrar's decision violated his charter rights to equality and to freedom of expression.
The case came before the country's top court after the Nova Scotia Court of Appeal unanimously ruled last August that the trial judge was right to conclude that Grabher's licence plate was not an area to which freedom of expression applied.
Writing on behalf of the three-judge appeal panel, Justice Cindy A. Bourgeois also noted that the licence plate could in fact be interpreted as a call to gender-based violence.
In Cameron's submission to the Supreme Court, he argued that the question to be settled by an appeal was whether government-owned personalized licence plates should be excluded from the scope of Charter of Rights and Freedoms' guarantees of "freedom of thought, belief, opinion and expression."
Grabher's case was not the first licence plate case to be taken on by the Alberta-based justice centre.
In June, 2020 the centre successfully got the Alberta Registrar of Motor Vehicles to reverse a decision denying Tomas Manasek his personalized FREE AB licence plate. It also won a case involving a Manitoba Indigenous man, who wanted his NDN CAR plate returned.
Another court challenge against Manitoba Public Insurance proved unsuccessful, after it had revoked the ASIMIL8 plate of an avid "Star Trek" fan because of a complaint that it was offensive to Indigenous people.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published March 17, 2022.
-- By Keith Doucette in Halifax
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Quebec man, 81, gets prison sentence after admitting to killing wife with Alzheimer's disease
An 81-year-old Quebec man has been sentenced to prison after admitting to killing his wife with Alzheimer's disease.
Canada Post quarterly loss tops $300M as strike hits second week -- and rivals step in
Canada Post saw hundreds of millions of dollars drain out of its coffers last quarter, due largely to its dwindling share of the parcels market, while an ongoing strike continues to batter its bottom line.
'Immoral depravity': Two men convicted in case of frozen migrant family in Manitoba
A jury has found two men guilty on human smuggling charges in a case where a family from India froze to death in Manitoba while trying to walk across the Canada-U.S. border.
Prime Minister Trudeau attends Taylor Swift's Eras Tour in Toronto with family
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is a Swiftie. His office confirmed to CTV News Toronto that he and members of his family are attending the penultimate show of Taylor Swift's 'The Eras Tour' in Toronto on Friday evening.
Trump supporters review-bomb B.C. floral shop by accident
A small business owner from B.C.'s Fraser Valley is speaking out after being review-bombed by confused supporters of U.S. president-elect Donald Trump this week.
Pat King found guilty of mischief for role in 'Freedom Convoy'
Pat King, one of the most prominent figures of the 2022 'Freedom Convoy' in Ottawa, has been found guilty on five counts including mischief and disobeying a court order.
Nearly 46,000 electric vehicles recalled in Canada over power loss risk
Nearly 46,000 electric vehicles from Kia, Hyundai and Genesis are being recalled in Canada over a potential power loss issue that can increase the risk of a crash.
Trump chooses Bessent to be Treasury secretary and Vought as top budget official
President-elect Donald Trump announced Friday that he'll nominate hedge fund manager Scott Bessent, an advocate for deficit reduction, to serve as his next treasury secretary. Trump also said he would nominate Russel Vought to lead the Office of Management and Budget.
Canada's tax relief plan: Who gets a cheque?
The Canadian government has unveiled its plans for a sweeping GST/HST pause on select items during the holiday period. The day after the announcement, questions remain on how the whole thing will work.