Public safety minister suggests Ashley Smith not a victim
A hood is placed over Ashley Smith's head in this 2007 surveillance video that was released in the corner's inquest into her death on Wednesday, Oct. 31, 2012.
THE CANADIAN PRESS
Published Tuesday, November 6, 2012 7:08PM AST
OTTAWA -- Opposition critics denounced Public Safety Minister Vic Toews as cold-hearted and contemptible Tuesday after he appeared to suggest that Ashley Smith -- a troubled teen who choked to death in prison as guards stood watch -- was not a victim.
Toews raised the ire of opposition parties when he deflected questions about Smith's death by accusing the NDP of caring more about prisoners than their victims.
His strategy was at odds with Prime Minister Stephen Harper, who last week called Smith's death a tragedy and ordered the Correctional Service of Canada to drop efforts to limit the scope of an inquest into the circumstances surrounding her death.
Harper's sympathetic response followed the release of disturbing videos of the teen's time in prison, which showed Smith being duct-taped by guards and injected against her will with powerful anti-psychotic drugs.
Under repeated questioning Tuesday by New Democrats in the House of Commons, Toews initially stuck to the script.
"This tragedy continues to show that individuals with mental health issues do not belong in prisons but in professional facilities," he said, going on to enumerate various measures the Harper government has implemented to deal with the problem.
But he then launched into a partisan attack.
"I would note that the NDP, while consistently speaking on behalf of prisoners, never speaks on behalf of the victims of these prisoners," he said, urging New Democrats to take "a more balanced view about what it means to have a safe society."
NDP Leader Tom Mulcair sprang to his feet with a short riposte: "Is that minister capable of understanding that she (Smith) was the victim here?"
Undeterred, Toews doubled down on his attack.
"I would like to ask that member (Mulcair), who has never once stood and spoken for victims, why is it that he is always silent when it comes to victims outside of our prisons?"
Outside the Commons, a visibly angry Mulcair said Toews simply doesn't recognize that Smith was a victim of the corrections system's inability to cope with mental illness.
"Mr. Toews doesn't get that and it shows a cold-heartedness and a partisan streak that simply fails to recognize that we're dealing with a human being who was abominably treated by the system and who wound up dying," said Mulcair.
"And, instead of showing compassion and care and responsibility for that, he turned it into his typical partisan rant and it's beneath contempt the way the minister answered this afternoon."
Interim Liberal leader Bob Rae called Toews' remarks "completely unacceptable."
"I think he's lowered the tone," Rae said.
"I think by choosing to turn it into some kind of a partisan issue, he shows that, frankly, he just doesn't get it. And it shows that he doesn't really understand to what extent Ms. Smith really in this particular case is clearly the victim."
A spokeswoman for Toews later sent a lengthy email reiterating his view that the Smith case "is a very tragic incident" that demonstrates the need to find alternatives to prison for the mentally ill. She did not address the controversy over the minister's earlier insinuation that Smith was not a victim.
Smith, who was from Moncton, N.B., was first arrested at 13 for assault and causing a disturbance. She continued to find herself in trouble for making harassing phone calls and pulling a fire alarm, then was first thrown in jail at 15 for throwing crab apples at a postal worker.
She eventually wound up in the federal prison system where, during the last year of her life, she was transferred 17 times among nine different prisons. She spent much of her final year in segregation due to repeated instances of self-harm and choking herself.
Smith died at only 19 years of age in a Kitchener, Ont., prison after wrapping a strip of cloth around her neck and choking herself. Guards, who were standing watch outside her cell, did not step in. They maintain they were instructed not to intervene.
Please read our guidelines before commenting on stories.